Witt Differential Generator for Special Jack Symmetric Functions / Polynomials

Exploring some relations among the multinomial coefficients of OEIS A036038 and the compositional inversion formulas of A134264, A248120, and A248927, related to numerous combinatorial structures and areas of analysis, including noncrossing partitions and free probability,  I came across the Jack symmetric functions J_n^{\alpha}(x_1,x_2, ...) in an infinite number of variables as presented in “Some combinatorial properties of the Jack symmetric functions” by Stanley.

Equation a) on page 80 of his paper leads to an umbral generating formula for the related Jack symmetric polynomials (JSP)

 J_n^{\alpha}(x_1,x_2, ...,x_{n+1}) = (\hat{x}_1 + \hat{x}_2 + \cdots + \hat{x}_{n+1})^n,

where \hat{x}_k is to be regarded as a regular variable until the expression is reduced to monomials at which time it is to be evaluated as  \hat{x}_k^j = s_j (\alpha) \; x_k^j with s_j(\alpha)  =  1 (1+\alpha)(1+2 \alpha) \cdots (1+(j-1) \alpha), essentially the row polynomials of A094638 comprised of the Stirling numbers of the first kind.  For example,

J_2^{\alpha}(x_1,x_2,x_3) = (\hat{x}_1 + \hat{x}_2  + \hat{x}_3)^2

= \sum_{k=1}^3 \; \hat{x}_k^2 \; + \; 2 \; \sum_{i,j=1 ; i < j}^3 \; \hat{x}_i \; \hat{x}_j = m_{[2]}(\hat{x}_1,\hat{x}_2,\hat{x}_3) \; + \; 2 \; m_{[1,1]}(\hat{x}_1,\hat{x}_2,\hat{x}_3)

= s_2(\alpha) \; m_{[2]}(x_1,x_2,x_3) \; + \; 2 \; s_1(\alpha) \; s_1(\alpha) \; m_{[1,1]}(x_1,x_2,x_3)

= (1+\alpha) \; m_{[2]}(x_1,x_2,x_3) \; + \; 2 \; m_{[1,1]}(x_1,x_2,x_3) ,

where the polynomial has been expressed in the symmetric monomial polynomials (SMP), easily extended to an indefinite number of variables. The factors multplying the SMPs are the multinomial coefficients of A036038 and remain independent of the number of variables. Each summand of an SMP has the same configuration of exponents and subscripts, allowing the products of s_k (\alpha) to be easily determined and factored out after the umbral evaluation.

Similarly, umbral reduction of x_k^j = x_j transforms J_n^0(x_1,..,x_{n+1}) into the partitions of A248120.

MOPS: Multivariate orthogonal polynomials (symbolically)” by Dumitriu, Edelman, and Shuman contain examples for the third and fourth JSPs, but the third has the coefficients erroneously transposed for the factorial.

Using the operator identities in A094638, a Rodriques-like generator for the JSPs can be devised.

(z^{1+y} \; D_z)^n = z^{ny} \; zD_z \; s_n (y \; zD_z),


z^{-1} \; z^{-ny} (z^{1+y} \; D_z)^n \; z = z^{-1} \;  zD_z \;s_n(y \; zD_z) \; z = s_n (y),

and, with w_k = 1/z_k^y

(\hat{x}_k)^j = z_k^{-1} \; w_k^j \; (z_k^{1+y} \; D_{z_k})^j \; x_k^j \; z_k = s_j(y) \; x_k^j

= z_k^{-1} (x_k \; \hat{w}_k \; z_k^{1+y} \; D_{z_k})^j \; z_k ,

with \hat{w}_k treated as independent of z_k with respect to the derivations and, after being passed unscathed to the left of all derivations, is finally evaluated as   \hat{w_k} = 1/z_k^y .

Then, with Q = \prod_{k>0} \; z_k,

J_n^y = Q^{-1} \; [\sum_{k>0} \; x_k \; \hat{w}_k \; z_k^{1+y} \; D_{z_k}]^n \; Q .

This may be generalized just as the Laguerre polynomials are to the associated Laguerre polynomials by conjugating with Q^u rather than Q .

A generating function for the full set of JSPs is

\exp[t\; J.^y] = Q^{-1} \; \prod_{k>0} \; \exp[t \; x_k \; \hat{w_k} \; z_k^{1+y} \; D_{z_k}] \; Q .

This can be evaluated by noting, with

\sigma = z^{-y}/(-y) and L_y = z^{1+y} \; \frac{d}{dz} = \frac{d}{d\sigma},


e^{\beta \; L_y} f (z) = e^{\beta \; \frac{d}{d\sigma}} \; f[(-y\sigma)^{-1/y}] = f[(-y (\sigma +\beta))^{-1/y}].

Then, for \beta =  t \; x_k \; \hat{w_k} and f(z)= z , the operation reduces to

[-y(\sigma+\beta)]^{-1/y} = [z^{-y}-t \; y \; x_k \; \hat{w_k}]^{-1/y} = z / [1-t \;y \; x_k \; \hat{w}_k \; z^y]^{1/y}.

Then the generator gives, since ultimately \hat{w_k} = 1/z_k^y ,

e^{t \; J.^y} = \prod_{k>0} \;  [1-t \; y \; x_k]^{-1/y},


e^{t \; J.^\alpha} = \prod_{k>0} \;  [1-t \; \alpha \; x_k]^{-1/\alpha}.

You can use the generalized Leibnitz formula to relate this back to the multinomial coefficients:

D_t^m \; \prod_{k=1}^{n+1} g_k(t) = (D_1  + D_2 + \cdots + D_{n+1})^m \; \prod_{k} g_k(t)

where D_j acts as d/dt only on g_j(t).

The e.g.f. is naturally consistent with the e.g.f. for A094638, which with a change of notation is

e^{s.(\alpha)x} = (1-\alpha x)^{-1/ \alpha},

and is an e.g.f. for plane m-ary trees with \alpha = m-1, so

\prod_k \; (1-\alpha x_kt)^{-1/ \alpha} = \prod_k \; e^{s.(\alpha)x_kt} = \prod_k \; e^{\hat{x}_k t} = e^{tJ.^{\alpha}}.

Therefore, the discussions in A134264 and the Hirzebruch criterion post below on repeated exponentiaton of an e.g.f., binomial convolutions, and umbral substitution apply to these calculations when x_k=x , giving connections among the OEIS entries cited at the top here and the multinomial coefficients.

Taking the log of the e.g.f. gives a relation between the symetric power sum polynomials / functions of the variables / indeterminates and the cumulants formed from the JSPs through A127671, or A263634.

Added 12/4/2016:

There are several other op reps for the JSPs.

s_n(\alpha)x^n = \alpha^n \; \frac{(xD+1/\alpha-1)!}{(1/\alpha-1)!}\; x^n ,

so another rep is

J^\alpha_n = [\prod_{k} \; \frac{(x_k D_{x_k}+1/\alpha-1)!}{(1/\alpha-1)!}\;] \; \alpha^n \; J^0_n

= [\prod_{k} \; (x_k D_{x_k})! \; K(1-1/\alpha,1,-:x_kD_{x_k}:)] \; \alpha^n \; J^0_n ,

= [\prod_{k} \; (x_k D_{x_k})! \; D_{x_k}^{1/\alpha-1}\frac{x_k^{1/\alpha-1}}{(1/\alpha-1)!}] \; \alpha^n \; J^0_n ,

where K(a,b,x) is the Kummer confluent hypergeometric function  (see also earlier posts) and by definition :xD:^n=x^nD^n . The reader can use the series expansion for the Kummer function in terms of rising factorials, the transformation \binom{u-1+n}{n} = (-1)^n \binom{-u}{n}, and the Chu-Vandermonde identity to confirm that

(xD_{x})! \; K(1-1/\alpha,1,-:xD_{x}:)] \; x^m = \frac{(m+1/\alpha-1)!}{(1/\alpha-1)!}\; \;x^m.


Added Dec 11, 2016:

Note that s_n(x)/(1+x) are the row polynomials of reversed, unsigned http://oeis.org/A049444 and reversed http://oeis.org/A143491.

This entry was posted in Math and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Witt Differential Generator for Special Jack Symmetric Functions / Polynomials

  1. Tom Copeland says:

    Note that s_n(x)/(1+x) are the row polynomials of reversed, unsigned http://oeis.org/A049444 and reversed https://oeis.org/A143491.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s